Breaking News & Top Stories


European ‘honey laundering’ fightback targets Chinese sugar syrup

EU nations are pushing again towards an inflow of syrup-laced honey from China and different exporters that’s flooding the bloc’s €2.3bn market and driving down costs.

The drive by 20 member states, led by Slovenia, to tighten regulation towards what one official dubbed “honey laundering” follows a European Fee examine that discovered a surge in fraud. Nearly half of the honeys surveyed broke EU guidelines, with elements comparable to sugar syrups, colourings and water, in accordance with findings printed final month.

“It’s mainly sugar water,” stated one EU official.

As a result of imported merchandise are bought at a lower cost than the European product, beekeepers throughout the continent stated honey fraud risked hurting small companies, deceptive shoppers and, by discouraging would-be apiarists, posing a danger to bees’ environmental function.

“There’s unfair competitors coming from exterior the EU, principally China,” stated Yvan Hennion, an apiarist with 300 hives in Halluin, northern France. “It’s not actual honey and it’s making the worth plummet.”

The 20 member states known as this week for brand new guidelines on honey labelling and a strengthening of checks to make detecting fraudulent samples simpler, officers stated. It follows an earlier proposal on honey labelling led by Slovenia in January.

4 in 5 jars bought in supermarkets are blends, typically together with honey from each inside and out of doors the bloc. A proposal by Slovenia has known as for EU honey labels to point every nation of origin and their respective share in blends, reasonably than the present method of merely stating that blends comprise a mixture of EU and non-EU honey.

The nations additionally need the fee to enhance its detection of honey that has been adulterated and enhance the variety of labs authorized to evaluate it.

“We wish traceability and an finish to trafficked honey,” stated an official backing the proposal.

On Friday, the fee proposed labelling every nation of origin in blends of honey however didn’t help options to incorporate percentages of how a lot honey got here from every nation, citing value constraints on operators.

Nonetheless, an official from a member state who was concerned within the negotiations warned this may not be sufficient to deal with the issue, and known as for particular wording on “traceability” of honey to be included.

4 in 5 jars of honey bought in supermarkets are blends, typically together with honey from each inside and out of doors the EU © Ute Grabowsky/Photothek/Getty Pictures

Regardless of the requires a clampdown, the EU depends on imports to satisfy the calls for of its sweet-toothed inhabitants. It produces 218,000 tonnes of honey but additionally imports 175,000 tonnes per 12 months, with the overwhelming majority coming from simply eight locations, together with China, Ukraine, Turkey and a number of other Latin American nations.

The fee examine, carried out from 2021 to 2022, discovered that 46 per cent of honey samples surveyed broke EU guidelines, a determine that had risen from simply 14 per cent within the interval between 2015 and 2017. Some 70 of 123 corporations assessed had exported honey suspected of containing sugar syrups, which will be made extra cheaply than the real article.

Of these exporters, 21 got here from China, greater than some other nation, adopted by Ukraine.

Adulterated jars additionally got here from Argentina, Brazil, Mexico and Turkey, whereas each operator surveyed from Nice Britain had exported at the very least one jar suspected of failing to satisfy EU guidelines. Researchers stated the discovering was most likely the results of honey from different nations being repackaged within the UK, though the UK’s general exports to the EU have been comparatively low.

Hennion stated that whereas direct gross sales from his farm had held up nicely, the costs he obtained from wholesalers had dropped lately. He costs wholesalers at the very least €3.50 per kilo of honey however imported honey will be purchased for lower than €1.

This damage all the bee-based economic system, stated Hennion, who additionally sells queen bees to these beginning apiary companies.

“The whole lot goes collectively,” he stated. “The honey is bought at a very good worth, the vendor sells gear, beekeepers arrange, we promote queen bees. It’s a round, bee career that we should keep.”

Stanislav Jaš, a Finland-based beekeeper and chair of the honey working social gathering for European farming teams Copa and Cogeca, stated he was pressured to promote extra honey on to shoppers than on a wholesale foundation due to the autumn in costs.

Whereas he was “completely satisfied” that the fee’s proposal will enhance transparency for shoppers, Jaš stated it “lacked ambition” to deal with fraud and help European producers.

“The chances aren’t there and so they haven’t talked about the fraud situation or laboratory testing,” he added. “We’re going to work with the Council and the European Parliament to enhance the proposal.”

The beekeeping business was very important to the atmosphere and agriculture due to bees’ function in pollination, Jaš and Hennion stated.

Pollinators together with honey bees contribute €22bn annually to the European agriculture business and pollinate 80 per cent of crops and wild crops within the continent, in accordance with EU figures. They face a decline attributable to pesticides, air pollution and different components, which the EU has stated it needs to reverse by 2030.

Hennion is a “pastoral” beekeeper, or a “flower chaser”, he says. To make sure his bees have entry to rapeseed, he repeatedly travels with them from the Ardèche in southern France to Halluin, a city on the Belgian border.

This lifestyle, and that of different beekeepers in Europe, was in danger if costs remained low, stated Aapo Savo, a Finnish honey packer who works with 150 Finnish beekeepers to pack honey into containers which are then bought on to supermarkets.

“What’s the future {of professional} beekeeping in Europe?” Savo stated. “On a regular basis it is going to be harder to provide honey. I don’t suppose it’s sustainable.”